Today, on the floor of the Senate, Senator John McCain (R-AZ) appeared briefly to give a speech to his colleagues on why he was voting for the Motion to Proceed on Obamacare repeal/replace legislation. He also explained why he doesn’t intend on voting for the bill itself as written. However, he gave a master class on Senate history, the purpose of our Republican government, and why he felt it was necessary at times to do things he did not agree with.
You and I will find many things to dislike in what he said. But, we’ll likewise find many things to cheer for.
Either way, this speech will likely go down as one of the great speeches by a Senator in the modern era. This is not an exaggeration. His 2,000 word speech contained both history, reflection, reverence for the founders, defense of federalism, America’s destiny, and even took a swipe at his own party – then waited for applause from one side – just to take a swipe at the other party for their irony. It brought much needed laughter to a floor too often full of bloviating and partisan bickering.
It’s worth reading, and sharing.
“I stand before you today, looking a little worse for wear I’m sure. I have a refresh appreciation for protocols and customs of this body, and for the other 99 privileged souls who’ve been elected to the Senate.
I’ve been a member of the United States Senate for 30 years. I had another long, if not as long career before I arrive here. Another profession that was profoundly rewarding, in which I had experiences and friendships that I revered. But make no mistake. My service here is the most important job I’ve had in my life.
I’m so grateful to the people of Arizona for the privilege, the honor of serving here and the opportunities he gives me to play a small role in the history of the country I love. I’ve known and admired men and women in the Senate that played much more than a small role in our history. True statesmen, giants of American politics. They come from both parties, and from various backgrounds.
Their ambitions were frequently in conflict. They held different views on issues of the day. And they often had very serious disagreements on how to best serve the national interest. But they knew that however sharp and heartfelt their disputes, however keen their ambitions, they had an obligation to work collaboratively to ensure the Senate discharged its constitutional responsibilities effectively. Our responsibilities are important, vitally important to the continuing success of our Republic. Our arcane rules and customs are deliberately intended to require broad cooperation to function well at all.
The most revered members of this institution accepted the necessity of compromise in order to make incremental progress on solving America’s problems, and defend her from her adversaries. That principled mindset, and the service of our predecessors who possessed it come to mind when I hear the Senate referred to as “the worlds greatest deliberative body.” I’m not sure we can clean the distinction with a straight face today. I’m sure it wasn’t always deserved in previous years either, but I’m sure there have been times when it was. And I was privileged to witness some of those occasions.
Our deliberations today, not just our debates, but the exercise of all of our responsibilities – authorizing government policies, appropriating funds to implement them, exercising our advise and consent role – are often lively and interesting. They can be sincere and principled. But we are more partisan, more tribal, more of the time that I’ve any time that I can remember. Our deliberations can still be important and useful, but I think we’d all agree, they haven’t been over burdened by greatness lately.
Right now, they aren’t producing much for the American people.
Both sides have let this happen. Let’s leave the history of who shot first to the historians. I suspect they’ll find we all conspired in our decline, either by deliberative actions or neglect. We’ve all played some role in it. Certainly, I have. Sometimes, I’ve let my passion rule my reason. Sometimes, I’ve made it harder to find common ground because of something harsh I said a colleague. Sometimes, I wanted to win more for the sake of winning, than to achieve a contested policy.
Incremental progress, compromises each side criticize but also accept, just plain muddling through to chip away at at problems and keep our enemies from doing their worst isn’t glamorous, or exciting. It doesn’t feel like a political triumph. But it’s usually the most we can expect from our system of government, operating in a country as diverse and quarrelsome and free as ours. Considering the injustice and cruelties inflicted by autocratic governments, and how corruptible human nature can be, the problem-solving our system does make possible, the fitful progress it produces, and the liberty and justice it preserves is a magnificent achievement.
Our system doesn’t depend on our nobility. It accounts for our imperfections, and gives us an order to our individual strivings that has helped to make ours the most powerful and prosperous society on earth. It is our responsibility to preserve that. Even when it requires us to do something less satisfying than “winning.” Even when we must give a little to get a little. Even when our efforts managed just three yards in a cloud of dust while critics on both sides denounce us for timidity, for our failure to “triumph.”
I hope we can again rely on humility, on our need to cooperate, on our dependence on each other, and learn how to trust each other again. And by so doing, better serve the people who elected us. Stop listening to the bombastic loudmouths on the radio and television and Internet.
To hell with them! *applause*
They don’t want anything done for the public good. Our incapacity is their livelihood. Let’s trust each other. Let’s return to regular order. We’ve been spinning our wheels on too many important issues because we keep trying to find a way to win without help from across the aisle. That’s an approach that’s been employed by both sides, mandating legislation from the top down without any support from the other side, with all the parliamentary maneuvers that requires. We’re getting nothing done, my friends. We are getting nothing done!
And all we’ve really done this year is confirm Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court.
Our healthcare insurance system is a mess. We all know it. Those who support Obamacare, and those who oppose it. Something has to be done. We Republicans have looked for a way to end it and replace it with something else without paying a terrible political price. We haven’t found it yet. And I’m not sure we will. All we’ve managed to do is make more popular a policy that wasn’t very popular when we tried getting rid of it. I voted for the motion to proceed to allow debate to continue, and amendments to be offered.
I will not vote for this bill as it is today. It’s a shell of a bill right now. We all know that. I have changes urged by my state’s governor that will have to be included to earn my support for final passage of any bill.
I know many of you will have to see the bill changed substantially for you to support it. We tried to do this by coming up with a proposal behind closed doors, in consultation with the administration. Then springing it on skeptical members, trying to convince them that it’s better than nothing. It’s better than nothing? Asking us to swallow our doubts and force it past a unified opposition… I don’t think that’s going to work in the end. And probably shouldn’t.
The administration and congressional Democrats shouldn’t have forced through Congress, without any opposition support a social and economic change as massive as Obamacare. And we shouldn’t do the same with ours.
Why don’t we try the old way of legislating in the Senate? The way our rules and customs encourage us to act, if this process ends in failure – which seems likely – then let’s return to regular order. Let the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee under chairman Alexander & ranking member Murray hold hearings, try to write a bill of committee with contributions from both sides. *Democrats applaud*
Something that my dear friends on the other side of the aisle didn’t allow to happen nine years ago. *Republicans applaud/laugh*
Let’s see if we can pass something that will be imperfect, full of compromises, and not very pleasing to implacable partisans on either side, but that might provide workable solutions to problems Americans are struggling with today. What have we to lose by trying to work together to find those solutions? We are not getting much done apart.
I don’t think very many of us feel very proud of our incapacity. Merely preventing your political opponents from doing what they want isn’t the most inspiring work. There’s greater satisfaction in respecting our differences, but not letting them prevent agreements that don’t require abandonment of core principles – agreements made in good faith to help improve lives and protect the American people.
The Senate is capable of that. We know that. We’ve seen it before. I’ve seen it happen many times, and the times when I was involved, even in a modest way, working on a bipartisan response to a national problem or threat are the proudest moments of my career. And by far the most satisfying.
This place is important. The work we do here is important. Our strange rules and seemingly eccentric practices that slow our proceedings and insist on our cooperation are important. Our Founders envisioned the Senate as the more deliberative, careful body that operates at a greater distance than the other body from the public passions of the hour.
We are an important check on the powers of the executive. Our consent is necessary for the president to appoint jurists and powerful Government officials, and in many respects, to conduct foreign policy. Whether or not we are of the same party, we are not the President’s subordinates. We are his equal.
As his responsibilities are onerous, many and powerful, so are ours. We play a vital role in shaping and directing the judiciary, the military, the cabinet, and the planning and supporting foreign and domestic policies. Our success in meeting all these awesome constitutional obligations depends upon cooperation among ourselves.
The success of the Senate is important to the continuing success of America. This country, this big, boisterous, brawling, intemperate, restless, striving, daring, beautiful, bountiful, brave, good and magnificent country needs us to help at thrive. That responsibility is more important than any of our personal interest, or political affiliation.
We are the servants of a great nation. A nation conceived in liberty and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal.
More people have live free and prosperous lives here than in any other nation. We’ve acquired unprecedented wealth and power because of our governing principles, and because our government defend of those principles. America’s made a greater contribution than any other nation to an international order that has liberated more people from tyranny and poverty than ever before in history. We have been the greatest example, the greatest supporter, and the greatest defender of that role. We aren’t afraid. We don’t covet other people’s land and wealth.
We don’t hide behind walls. We breach them. We are a blessing to humanity.
What greater cause could we hope to serve than in helping keep America the strong, aspiring, inspirational beacon of liberty and defender of dignity of all human beings, and their right to freedom, and equal justice? That is the cause that binds us, and is so much more powerful and worthy than the small differences that divide us.
What a great honor, and extraordinary opportunity it is to serve in this body. It is a privilege to serve with all of you. I mean it. Many of you have reached out in the last few days with your concern and your prayers. And it means a lot to me. It really does. I’ve had so many people say such nice things about me recently, that I think some of you must have me confused with someone else. *laughter*
I appreciate it though. Every word. Even if much of it isn’t deserved.
I’ll be here for a few days. I’ll help managing the floor debate on the defense authorization bill, which I’m proud to say is again a product of bipartisan cooperation and trust among the members of the Senate Armed Services Committee. After that, I’m going home for a while to treat my illness. I have every intention of returning here and giving many of you cause to regret all the nice things you said about me. And I hope to impress on you again that it is an honor to serve the American people, in your company.
Thank you, fellow senators.
Mr. President, I yield the floor.”