To the left of Hillary

Hillary and Barack are scrambling to get to the left of John Edwards on a host of issues, but there is one issue on which Barack Obama has been consistently to the left of Hillary Clinton — the birth of children.

In partial birth abortion, a baby is born while the doctors are careful to leave the child partially in the birth canal. Then an incision is made in the back of the baby’s head and its brains are vacuumed out. The child, being old enough, is aware and feeling.

Throughout his political career, Barack Obama has been a supporter of the procedure.

In 2004, as a candidate Barack Obama sent out a fundraising appeal against it.

U.S. Senate candidate Barack Obama’s wife, Michelle, sent a fund-raising letter with the “alarming news” that “right-wing politicians” had passed a law stopping doctors from stabbing half-born babies in the neck with scissors, suctioning out their brains and crushing their skulls.

Michelle called partial-birth abortion “a legitimate medical procedure,” and wouldn’t supporters please pay $150 to attend a luncheon for her husband, who would fight against “cynical ploy[s]” to stop it?

In 2003, while in the Illinois legislature, Barack Obama chaired the Illinois Senate committee that dealt with the Born Alive Infant Protection Act (“BAIPA”), a measure beyond the PBA that any sane person should support. The act mandating live saving medical treatment for infants born alive, as some children are born even though an abortion has been attempted. Obama refused to allow the committee to consider the legislation. He *refused* a hearing and shelved the legislation.

That’s to the left of Hillary Clinton’s position and NARAL’s position, which was neutral on consideration of the BAIPA.*

And some of you people would rather Obama than John McCain. Pitiful.

*Updated: As SIConservative notes here, I made the mistake of equating the PBA and BAIPA. Clinton, Ted Kennedy, etc. supported the BAIPA, though Obama opposed it. Both Clinton and Obama opposed the PBA. I have fixed the post to resolve the confusion and correct the error.

Put another way, Hillary and Obama agree that until a baby is fully from the womb, it can be slaughtered. But, Hillary believes that once the baby is all the way out, you cannot slaughter it. Obama disagrees and supports killing fully born children.

About the author

Erick Erickson

View all posts


  • What’s interesting to me is that Obama’s opposition to the BAIPA is the reason Alan Keyes says he agreed to come to Illinois and challenge Obama in the U.S. Senate race, and why he said that “Jesus Christ would not vote for Obama.” Gotta admit, pretty good reasons, especially now that folks are realizing just what kind of guy Obama is.

  • For give My Spelling I’m dislectic

    OBama, Hillery Or a Man that Has Discovered A New Way for Repubicans to Win Rap the land and put it into Hock to China and let Pink Eliphents Have gay Weddings and Abort there Kids!
    How do you thing Mitt Became Governer of Mass.
    Let them Pray on the Most Vonerable in Our Nation and let them rip Babies from there Mothers Whom thats You Big City east coast and West Coast Republican Rudy Of Crack why do you think the Democrats do so well on the east coast and West Coast A Large Chunk are disusted with Rudy Republican but do the Math you Plus Rudy = permant Republcan majority you – rudy = republicans loseing so what you ask of the dems they can’t do becuse then rudy Republican vote overwelingly republican.
    that’s why in polls Only Rudy and Mc.Cain have a snowballs chance in Hell!. come Nov.

    here is What the Cherch Looks Like to someone No in love with the G.Globaliziaion and O.Occupation P.Party also Known as the G.O.P.

    And Know this I’m A Born Again Evangelical Christin the Only differentc between meny Of you and My self In 25 years old and I read the Bible and belvie it Unlike meny of You.

    Befor Reading this Know I like Capitalisum But only within the Holy Moreal Law Of Jesus Christ.

    Obamas My Canidate Well for many resons
    one All the voter that will Vote for men that scerem Christ from the Rooftop then naver miss a Chance to be Evil or Help Rich Foke sperde the Most Evil thing much as CAFTA and these Men seem by there actions to Beleve Inter Class Relations Must be perediter Vs Pray.

    So since Fake Evangelicals and and Fake Southeren Baptist have taken it apon them selves to say to all the “Red State” Free Trater It’s Ok to Ignore the santity of Human Life When it leves the Whom
    do what ever you wish to it Rape it kill it pliage it poison it nagect it leave it for Dead let Bush Help WALL-MART Pay the “RED STATE” Of China point a Gun in the Face Of Human Life and say Work for Free Or Die that What Christanity In America Is today A Rabbid Political Right-wing Slaned Machine that Made a Deal with the Devil You ban Abortion and we will Let you Rape Pliage and Punder

    this also explains why the Cherch has declined ever since Raegin Because Raegin the Pagin Didn’t Die For Sinners ‘O’! how Dair I Insalt the god of the Republcan Party Easy Because Jesus Christ Is My God who is alive sitting at the right Hand Of my hevenly Farther the Jesus That sends the Holy Sperit to all that have called on the Name of Jesus Christ of Nazzerith and are save

    For I tell you the Truth Your are all A Breud Of Viper Mitt Rommny is a Pro-Life Viper as Pagin as the Day is long for he has Raegin the Pagin as his father and so do Most of You

    Yours Truly a Grassroots Net Roots Democrat for Obama be cause as to spite another one of your articals most are and Obama he is still better then your ga#.. I mean guys